Monday, October 6, 2025

Review: "A Place for People Like Us" by Danila Botha

A Place for People Like Us by Danila Botha
A Place for People Like Us by Danila Botha
Published September 2025 via Guernica Editions
★★★


To Hannah, Jillian is everything that is cool—not always stable, and not always kind, but magnetic. They're friends and they're lovers and then they're friends again, especially as Hannah dives deep into a new relationship that will ultimately ask her to change just about everything about herself. But, well, not everything is as it seems.

I read this partly for the friendship side of things (I love books about friendship) and partly for the complicated religion side of things (...ditto). The religion side of things is fascinating, if sad: Hannah, who grew up in a cult (here I should note that there are some graphic depictions of CSA within her memories of that experience), falls for Naftali, who is an Orthodox Jew, and it becomes clear that the relationship can only progress if she converts. Naftali is happy with a conversion on paper, but it quickly becomes clear that his family is more complicated, and no matter what Hannah does she's going to be giving part of herself up.

The friendship side of things opens the book, loses some focus as Hannah dives deeper into Judaism and her relationship, and then comes back in full force later in the book—because Jillian is not well, and Hannah and Naftali represent one of the more reliable parts of her life. I wasn't entirely sure what to make of that plot line; it's clear for much of the book that there are things that Jillian isn't saying, but Hannah can't or doesn't want to hear it anyway. By then the book is moving faster through time, months passing where days might have before, and Hannah's life is so detached from what it was at the beginning of the book that it's hard to recognize.

The writing was a little hit-or-miss for me. There's a lot of exposition through dialogue, in a way that didn't feel very natural to me. I think I also wanted to see...mm, I'm not quite sure how to put this, but I'm not sure if Hannah ever really considers the consequences of what she's deciding throughout the book. She gets on one train and then another, and if she ever stops to wonder whether she might be able to choose her destination, I'm not sure we see it. The climax of the book comes late, with a hiss and a crash, and if one thing is clear it's that she'll have to find a new train. I do love how messy it gets (there comes a point when Hannah simply doesn't have a lot of good options, and it's also clear that her upbringing hasn't left her with all that many good options), and I'd love to see what Botha might do with either a less dialogue-heavy book or perhaps a script written for the stage.

Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.

Saturday, October 4, 2025

Review: "Food School" by Jade Armstrong

Food School by Jade Armstrong
Food School by Jade Armstrong
Published April 2024 via Conundrum Press
★★★★


A pleasant surprise. Food School is a quick graphic novel about a woman in an adult intensive outpatient program for an eating disorder. There's not a ton here that's new, but a couple of things that feel notable: first, this is about trying to get better, not about being sick. That might seem like a small distinction, but (take it from somebody who has read too much in specific genres and subgenres and subsubgenres...) it's actually a significant one. Second, Armstrong is good about avoiding (or rather, redacting) things that are realistic in the context of the story but that could be triggering to some readers. And third, while it's not unheard of to have an adult protagonist in this sort of thing, it's still uncommon, and it's nice to see Olive trying to figure out recovery (and I mean: genuinely trying, even when she hates being in the program and hates everyone around her and hates everything about it; she's often ambivalent and doesn't always get it right, but she knows why she's there) while also trying to adult. The ending is abrupt, but overall the story worked better for me than I expected.

Thursday, October 2, 2025

Review: "Portraits of Cape Breton" by Alfred LeBlanc

Portraits of Cape Breton by Alfred LeBlanc
Portraits of Cape Breton by Alfred LeBlanc
Published May 2024 via SPP Publications
★★★★


What the title says: portraits taken in communities on Cape Breton. The book was published in 2024 but many of the portraits taken some 30 years ago, and I'm guessing things look rather different now—the world was just a different place in the 90s. But I'm reminded of Appalachian Legacy, I think, in the way we're seeing a wee little slice of things for a handful of individuals. Curious about why so many of these portraits are of older folks (perhaps LeBlanc was trying to capture a generation that even at the time was fading out?), but I love the little descriptions under many of the photos; they don't provide a full life story, but they offer an anecdote or a bit of context or a bit of colour.

Says LeBlanc: You might ask, why black and white? Most photography, including my own, is done in colour. That's how we see the world. Colour is an important part of the beauty we see in the world around us. So why do black and white? Colour 'pretends' to capture reality. As such, I have frequently had a gut reaction of disappointment: "that doesn't capture the experience I had on that beach or in those mountains, or with that person". Black and white doesn't trigger that sentiment quite as much because it does not pretend to capture reality. It is clearly and unapologetically an abstraction. And, of course, it suits the subjects in this case, creating an appropriate mood in capturing older people in somewhat traditional settings. (VII)

Tuesday, September 30, 2025

Review: "Overdue" by Stephanie Perkins

Overdue by Stephanie Perkins
Overdue by Stephanie Perkins
Published October 2025 via Saturday Books
★★★★


Ingrid has been stuck in somebody else's dream job for too long. (You might say she's overdue for a new job.) Her coworker Macon goes a long way to keeping that position tolerable—but Ingrid has never been able to act on her attraction, because she has a long-term boyfriend. But when Ingrid and her boyfriend Cory agree to take a month-long break, a hiatus to explore dating other people (which they both think is...overdue) before getting back together and planning their long-awaited (overdue?) wedding, it seems like the perfect chance to hook up with Macon.

One minor snag: Macon doesn't agree. And that complicates things.

I read all of Perkins' YA books back in the day, so I was eager to see what she'd do with an adult romance. This is both slow and lively: Overdue takes place over a year, and it's late in the book before Ingrid and Macon have a real conversation about their feelings and decide to give it a go; consequently, a lot of the book is about Ingrid dating around with other people, and figuring out next steps with her career, and building a stronger platonic friendship with Macon. It sounds like some of the career stuff might be inspired by Perkins' own trajectory, though of course I don't know how much of it.

Two favorite things about the book: first, there are no evil exes. I comment on this all the time when I read romance novels, so I know I'm a broken record here, but I love it when the ex is allowed to be, like...just a person. A good person, even! Just not the right person. Cory, Ingrid's boyfriend-turned-temporary-ex-turned-whatever could so easily be a cliché; instead, he's allowed to be a decent person and decent boyfriend who just isn't sure that this is the right relationship for him. He and Ingrid talk about their relationship and their break like the adults that they are, and when they get jealous or have questions they, well, talk it out. Macon's ex is a little less fleshed out, but she's not evil either—again, she's just not the right person for Macon. As ever, although this feels like a small thing, it does a lot of work to elevate the book. And the second, related thing: Ingrid does date around while on her break from Cory. Sometimes it's terrible one-off dates (I hope the more entertaining and less traumatic ones are pulled from real life), and sometimes things go further—and, again, it's not all smarmy assholes who are just after one thing. She meets good people and people she clicks with...and that doesn't mean it works out. Romance-novel heroines who get to date around in a way that is completely normal are freaking unicorns. (Weirdly, this was more common in 1960s romance...but I digress.)

All of this makes for a pretty slow burn, though. On the one hand I'm glad of it—I don't need (or want) a rapid-fire friends-to-lovers-in-under-two-weeks sort of thing. On the other hand I started wondering whether a plot point could be taken out to tighten the book somewhat. (Macon's mother, maybe? I get why she's there, and she adds a different dynamic to the relationship, but the stuff with his aunt might be enough.) I'm on the fence about the house makeover; part of it sounds delightful, but part of me thinks that it's a little...not red-flaggy, but yellow-flaggy for a friend you aren't actually all that close with yet to let you redo their house entirely in your style. (Also. This is neither here nor there, but the cupboards should have been white or wood, and the curtains should have been blue and white, dang it.)

At any rate, a nice shift to adult fiction—I'll be interested to see where Perkins goes next. I'm not quite sure where this lands for me on a no-half-stars scale, but let's call it 3.5 stars.

Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.

Sunday, September 28, 2025

Review: "Miss Matty" by Edeet Ravel

Miss Matty by Edeet Ravel
Miss Matty by Edeet Ravel
Published February 2025 via Linda Leith Publishing
★★★


Montreal, the early 1940s: Fran dreams of being a star—dreams of something far away from her humdrum life of poverty. Her secret boyfriend is away in the military, and she wants to be a young bride, to live in a beautiful house, perhaps to be so far away from her parents that she doesn't have to pretend not to know them in public. Her best friend Rita, who is comfortably middle class, has no such aspirations; she's just happy to be falling in love and enjoying life as a teenager.

Overall I found Miss Matty to be a bit slow but interesting nonetheless. The chapters are loosely split between Fran and Rita, with occasional departures into letters and other material; Fran's story is a regular narrative, while Rita's side of things is told in diary entries. Fran is not a particularly appealing character—so desperate for a life other than her own that she is constantly scheming, secretly at battle with the world; she's also so head over heels for her secret boyfriend that she can't hear see of the warning signs—but that's actually what makes the book interesting. Rita, whose story has less plot, understands Fran perhaps better than Fran does herself, and so we see both Fran's self-perception (which really only becomes more accurately self-aware at the end of the book) and Rita's more realistic perception. One for readers of quiet books; the dual perspectives made it worth the read for me, but I was glad it wasn't longer.

Saturday, September 27, 2025

Review: "Call of the Camino" by Suzanne Redfearn

Call of the Camino by Suzanne Redfearn
Call of the Camino by Suzanne Redfearn
Published October 2025 via Lake Union Publishing
★★★★


Reina has long wanted to follow in her parents' footsteps and walk the Camino. And when a chance comes, she takes it—better yet, it's a chance to one-up a work rival. So off she goes in the present day...and meanwhile, in the 90s, another woman is setting off on her own, rather different, journey.

When I was preparing to walk the Camino, more than a decade(!) ago, I read everything I could get my hands on—which turned out to be almost exclusively memoirs plus the occasional more academic book. It's only recently that I've been seeing more Camino fiction, and I can't tell you how much joy I've gotten from that.

I didn't really check the details on this one before picking it up (because really, did I need to know anything other than Camino novel?), so it took me a moment to get used to the two timelines (I had it in my head that the book was about a few middle-aged friends walking together...I was wrong), but once I got used to that it was all go. One of the characters is from Andorra, which was a delight; I once went to Andorra la Vella as side trip from Barcelona, but I don't think I've ever read anything set there.

Some of the plot points didn't feel necessary to me (a few too many near-death experiences), but what I really loved was the way Redfearn's own experience on the Camino, and her respect for it, comes through. You don't have to have walked the Camino or really know anything about it in order to appreciate the book, but if you are familiar with the Camino, you'll recognize a lot of the moments Reina experiences here.

A minor note if you read this and are thinking about walking the Camino yourself: the Camino does not take a minimum of 33 days, as Reina claims; I walked from SJPdP in 30 days, I knew other people who walked the same distance in less time, and there are any number of starting points and routes that take different amounts of time. Don't let Reina's confident but ill-informed estimate put you off if you don't have a month or more!

Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.

Thursday, September 25, 2025

Review: "Cat" by Rebecca van Laer

Cat by Rebecca van Laer
Cat by Rebecca van Laer
Published October 2025 via Bloomsbury Academic
★★★


van Laer grew up with cats—cats and dogs and, really, something of a menagerie. More creatures than humans at times. And van Laer loved the dogs...but cats were her first love.

This is one of Object Lessons—a series of short books exploring ordinary objects. Now, whether cats can be called objects is debatable—I don't really think mammals are objects, so I'm going to go no, but Merriam-Webster is actually pretty vague on the subject, so let's run with it. The structure of the books varies, and for better or for worse I have fallen head over heels in love with the ones that are mostly history and research. What can I say? I'm a nerd. A catless-cat-lady nerd, as it happens, so I was hoping for some catnip for nerds.

Cat is largely memoir: an exploration of the cats that have helped to shape van Laer's life, first in childhood and then as an adult. She explores competing stereotypes of cat lovers and dog lovers—and, critically, what she needs in her life to be fulfilled. Numerous cats slink onto and off the page, but she focuses mostly on two: Gus, the cat van Laer brought into her relationship, and Toby, the cat her partner brought in.

I've heard it said that this is the key difference between pet owners: dog people wish their dogs were people; people wish that they were cats. (loc. 96*)

There's a lot of riffing here, which honestly feels kind of right for cats—I suspect that if cats could talk, many of them would be pretty selective about what they talked about...but a significant proportion would be good at riffing on whatever subject caught their attention. I could have used a bit more citation at times—there's a robust enough selection of references, but when van Laer suggests that people are more likely to return cats to shelters than they are to return dogs (she says this in the context of human allergies to pets, though within the context of the chapter it reads as a more general thing), I took myself down something of a rabbit hole to see what the data said. The short answer is that I still don't know, but one of the studies van Laer cites mentions the opposite (lower number of cat returns compared to dogs in study samples), and one of the studies that study cites looked at 3,204 dog relinquishments and 2,755 cat relinquishments, suggesting that there are in fact more dog relinquishments than cat relinquishments (in Denmark)...though this does not tell me whether this is proportional to the numbers of dog owners and cat owners, or pet dogs and cat dogs, or dog and cat adoptions, and I don't know if those numbers are generalizable to the US, so actually my research has done very little except prove that I am, in fact, still a nerd. How's that for a riff?

At any rate. This is a nice little memoir for cat lovers—though with the warning that if you have a hard time with discussions of pet deaths (van Laer talks about more than a few of them), this is likely not the book for you. (I'm generally unfazed by that sort of thing, but know yourself and your reading preferences.) I think I'm left wanting an Object Lessons book about animal shelters—to complete the research I didn't finish!

*Quotes are from an ARC and may not be final.

Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.

Tuesday, September 23, 2025

Review: "The Weaver Bride" by Lydia Gregovic

The Weaver Bride by Lydia Gregovic
The Weaver Bride by Lydia Gregovic
Published September 2025 via Delacorte Press
★★★


Lovett's life is a ticking time bomb: unless she marries a Weaver, who can use her magic to enhance his own, before she turns twenty-one, she will be banished to the cloisters to spin her hair into magic until her power wears out in a few years. What happens after that, nobody knows; nobody returns from the cloisters alive. And so when a chance to compete for the hand of a wealthy Weaver comes her way...well, she can't turn it down.

This feels like one for fans of The Selection and Wither. I'm probably dating myself with those references, but they're what I thought of, with this combination of reality-style competition and girls desperate to survive past their twenties. There are elements of a fairy tale here (a little bit of Sleeping Beauty, a little bit of Rumpelstiltskin), but what interested me most was Lovett's magical gift (her Wit, in book parlance): she can get through any door, regardless of locks. There's a moment when it seems like this will be an advantage, something to set her apart from her competition—and then you're reminded that every girl maiden ("maiden" count: 130) in the competition has a Wit, and some might prove more valuable than others. What do you think you could do the most with? One maiden can find anything, as long as she knows what she's searching for; one maiden can mark windows and look through them later; still another can force truth with a kiss. It's not clear if most silkwitches have Wits that are so useful for, well, sneakery, but I think it's probably more that the ten who have been chosen for this competition have been chosen partly on the grounds of their Wits.

I was a little disappointed not to see those Wits used more heavily. Oh, Lovett sneaks around the manor, and a few of the other maidens do some sneaking of their own, but mostly the competition is a bit passive—waiting to see how they will be judged. And judged they are: It takes Lovett well into the book to realize that it isn't a fair competition (the men doing the judging are looking for, among other things, a maiden who is powerful but docile), and that even if she wins, her life will not necessarily be easier. The men are not shy about their disdain for certain maidens, because magic or no magic, it is the men who have the power. Lovett is not really in it to marry the man who is this competition's prize, but I wish she were a little more strategic—she's conspiring with a man named Eliot to find out what happened to his sister in the previous year's competition, but every time he reminds her that they have to be subtle and he can't show her favor, she agrees and then gets wildly huffy when he doesn't immediately make his interest in her public. ("smirk" count, mostly the two of them: 43) She's a teenager, so I suppose there are hormones and underdeveloped brains to consider, but it ends up feeling like she rarely acts in her own best interests.

Judging by the ending, this will likely be spun into a duology or trilogy—in which case I'd hope to see a closer look at this convent that unmarried silkwitches are consigned to. Lovett probably still has quite a bit of untangling of her life to do before she can rest...

Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.

Sunday, September 21, 2025

Review: "Misty Copeland" by Gregg Delman

Misty Copeland by Gregg Delman
Misty Copeland by Gregg Delman
Published September 2016 via Rizzoli
★★★


Second of two books of photographs of Misty Copeland that I found at the library—after checking out the first one, I had to see how this would differ. This is more varied than Henry Leutwyler's take; the photos with Leutwyler look like they come from one photo shoot, with a uniform style, while the photos in Delman's book are from multiple shoots over multiple years. Some overtly balletic, in motion or still; some with Copeland in what appear to be costume pieces; some in simple leotards; some that would not look out of place in Vogue. (And, I think, some outtakes of a shoot for Copeland's memoir?) Again very limited words—a foreword by Copeland and an introduction by Delman (the latter a bit more interesting than the former, which holds little more than praise).

The photos are, again, great. It would be hard for them to be anything else! Not all to my style (a little too much sexy in places? Personal preference; I think I prefer ballet photos that are simpler but have explosive movement), but it's impossible to miss the skill on both sides of the camera. But what can I say—the word nerdery runs deep, and I'm reviewing my experience of "reading" this as a book, not just what I think of the photos themselves. My rating would have gone up with more words on these pages.

I do want to know: where are the photo books of other ballerinas? I'm not questioning why there are multiple books of photographs of Misty Copeland—you only need to look at a picture or two of her, or see her perform, to understand that (plus she either has a good PR team or is very good at PR herself). But why am I not also seeing books of photographs of...I don't know. Megan Fairchild, Isabella Boylston, etc.? Don't tell me Instagram has become the new coffee-table book!

Friday, September 19, 2025

Review: "Under a Spanish Sky" by T.A. Williams

Under a Spanish Sky by T.A. Williams
Under a Spanish Sky by T.A. Williams
Published September 2025 via Boldwood Books
★★★


2016: Amy and Luke are taking a slow road trip across Spain, loosely following the (or rather, a) pilgrimage route to Santiago. They're traveling together out of necessity rather than fully free choice, but something pulls them together.

1314: Aimee and Luc are taking the slow route across Spain, slipping on and off the (or rather, a) pilgrimage route to Santiago. They were not the ones meant to be making this trip, but necessity bands them together...and something else pulls at them too.

Now. I cannot resist a Camino book. I have tried, and I have failed, and frankly I no longer try. And this one is interesting for a couple of reasons: First, the parallel story. I've read very little Camino fiction (when I originally looked for some, I could find precious little other than some pulpy-looking murder mysteries, and it turned out that I was able to resist those), but the little fiction I have read has been entirely contemporary; the one other historical novel I have on my Camino shelf is not even about the Camino, and I read it because it was about a different pilgrimage and that was the closest I could get at the time. Although my fourteenth-century history is not exactly stellar (and for the most part I prefer contemporary fiction anyway), it's clear that research went into this, and I enjoyed both the historical details—especially the info about the Templars—and the contrast between now and then.

The second thing that is interesting is that both Amy and Aimee are blind, and relatively recently so. I was a little disappointed that the contemporary story did not involve a more traditional pilgrimage (that is: walking), as that would have added another dimension. But I come at this from a biased place (I miss the Camino), and I got over that disappointment fairly quickly while reading. It helps, of course, that the 1314 story is on foot! In any case, nice to have blind main characters: they experience the world from a different perspective than Luke and Luc, and they're both quick to establish that while there are things that others can help with, they're neither incompetent nor helpless.

A few quibbles: First, Luke's backstory is a Dramatic Backstory that doesn't serve much purpose other than to give him, well, a Dramatic Backstory. It might have worked if there had been more follow-up on it, but it kind of drops off the face of the earth Finisterre, and we're left in the dark about how his career (among other things) will move forward, and what that means for him and Amy. It's a weak spot in a well-crafted story. And second, there are odd comments here and there that either rub wrong (Luke's friend asking, ahead of time, if he'll be able to "cope" with escorting a very attractive woman—what, has this man no self-control?—or Amy assuring the reader that she had a friend make sure that Luke was good-looking before she agreed to travel with him...it took many chapters for her to regain my respect) or just don't make sense (Amy's comment about her "guardians," who are never mentioned again and who have no place in the life of a fully competent adult woman). They aren't dealbreakers, but they were headscratchers. I also couldn't quite decide how I felt about the way the storylines intersect—clever or contrived?—but on the whole it worked for me.

A satisfying addition to my Camino library.

Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.

Review: "Northern Girls" by Michelle Willms

Northern Girls by Michelle Willms Published April 2026 via Baraka Books ★★★★ A brief memoir-in-essays about growing up in northern Ontario—w...