Monday, September 5, 2022

Review: "Without a Homeland" by Bobbie Lord

 

Cover image of Without a Homeland

Without a Homeland by Bobbie Lord
Published February 2022 via Seascapes Press
★★★


Some twenty years ago, Bobbie Lord left for Albania to manage a refugee camp. It wasn't new work for her, but every situation and every culture is different, and not all challenges can be predicted.

Each latrine had two doors and a rudimentary stencil drawing of a man or a woman. Inside, the walls were rough to the touch. It was dark, and the air was stifling and hot. Footholds over the hole accommodated the stance of a man, but not that of women and children. (27)

Okay, that one is a challenge that could have been predicted—if even a single woman had been involved in the design of the latrines—but I do think that quotation illustrates some of the indignities of being a refugee: not enough to lost loved ones to war (or genocide); not enough to be driven out of your home, your town, your country; not enough to be forced to live in a constant state of uncertainty, without any choice in what you eat or when, or where you live or what health care you can get; not enough that it's suddenly no longer necessarily safe to take a shower (due to the risk of sexual assault)...but the fact that one of the most basic necessities of daily life, and something absolutely critical to a refugee camp, would be designed for—well, for the least vulnerable people in that camp, with no thought to the most vulnerable.

The book is somewhere between episodic and thematic. I'd have loved to see more development of some of the characters, though I imagine that would have been difficult more than twenty years after the fact. Perhaps most interesting is the fact that her time there included the formal end of the war—many of the people stuck in the refugee camp were able to go home, or to some version of home. To me that's intriguing just because I hear so often about refugee camps where people are stuck in limbo for years and years, with no resolution and no safe home to go to. Doesn't make the reality of returning to a war-torn home any easier, of course, but...interesting nonetheless.

Monday, August 29, 2022

Review: "Wellmania" by Brigid Delaney

Cover image of Wellmania

Wellmania by Brigid Delaney
Published August 2017 via Nero
★★★


Wellmania chronicles some of Delaney's steps in the quest for wellness—whatever that might mean. For Delaney, at various times, it meant dieting and fasts, yoga and meditation, colonics and spiritual retreats entailing multi-day hikes.

I found the whole thing a bit hit-or-miss for me in terms of how engaged I was as a reader, but that's largely because an enormous chunk of the middle is dedicated to yoga—and that's all good and well, and yoga is wonderful for many people, but I do not find it personally interesting in practice or in theory, and I don't find it interesting to read about other people's experiences with yoga.

But what does interest me is that Delaney is writing about this from a fairly balanced perspective—that is, recognising that many of the things she tried had no lasting impact, or made a difference only as long as she was laser-focused on them, or simply were not sustainable in the long run. Take this, abou
t the period after a challenging fast:
"I eventually ended up at the weight I started. What goes down must come up. Several months after I stopped fasting and the weight returned, my blood pressure levels went back to a high reading and I returned to taking blood pressure medication. But something in me had shifted. I think it was the knowledge that if I really wanted to lose a lot of weight, I could do it. But I was making a choice—and that choice was one of drinking and eating what took my fancy. Of enjoying food, and making it central. Of not saying no to anything (within reason). At other times of my life I might not see food in this way, but at this time I did. 
Dr Liu suggested I go on the full fast again—stop eating, and just start drinking the foul herbs, but my heart wasn't in it. I had been clean—achieved that almost miraculous, hard-fought place where it felt like every toxin harboured had exited my body. Getting to this level of clean was the wellness equivalent of Scientology's 'going clear'—the highest state of enlightenment you can achieve, a special place only a few can enter. But I didn't think I could do it again." (p. 83)

I'm opting not to include the details of the fast/detox that Delaney describes in the first section of the book, because frankly parts of that section would be, to some, like an instruction manual for an eating disorder. But I'm reminded of Starvation Heights, which details the way a 'fasting doctor' treated (and ultimately killed) many of her patients—the extreme fasts, the bruising massages, the sense that it is this or nothing. (Though, just in case it needs to be said—there is zero suggestion that Dr Liu of this book is killing his patients for their money.) I'm also reminded of a tabloid-y 'documentary' in which two journalists tried to get down to a US size 00 in a very short amount of time. One journalist picks a plan and basically sticks to it, though at the end she is very clear that she is ready to go back to eating normal food and maintaining a normal weight; the other bounces around and eventually develops eating disorder habits, like purging. In Wellmania, Delaney describes 'cheating' on her fast by chewing and spitting, itself an eating disorder behaviour (and for some a precursor to purging). Even as I understand that fasts can be valuable for some people in some situations, the whole thing here speaks to me more as...a sad part of an industry that is preying on people's insecurities, I guess, and on a culture that does not reward balance.

Other takeaways: Lululemon sells (or sold) $108 prayer beads (p. 135); at one point more than a fifth of all priests among the Benedictines in New Norcia had been accused of child sexual abuse (p. 148); Bali might be lovely but frankly it sounds like the western wellness industry has made it markedly less lovely; children are taught to fat-shame (and poverty-shame) from a young age...

"It reminds me of being at a supermarket in Sydney with a friend's children. The friend eats really well, and is into organic produce. We were walking down the aisles behind a family that you could describe as obese. The mum was putting chips, chocolate and frozen foods in their trolley. The children I was with laughed and pointed, but didn't call the family 'fat', they called them 'fat and poor'." (p. 78)
I...I would like to redescribe this friend who 'eats really well' as a friend who 'teaches her children toxic societal values'. (Early in the book, Delaney describes telling people not to put pictures on Facebook because she was at a weight she wasn't happy with (p. 6), and...oh, the whole thing just makes me sad.)

This is not the most cohesive review I have ever written, but there you go. Might appeal to people who are more interested in yoga and meditation...but if you're looking for something with even an inkling that a happy medium might be possible, well...look somewhere else, I guess.

Wednesday, March 23, 2022

Review: "Being Mary Bennet" by J.C. Peterson

 

Cover image for Being Mary Bennet

Being Mary Bennet by J.C. Peterson
Published March 2022 via HarperTeen
★★★★


A fun twist on an Austen retelling—this one from the perspective of the much-maligned Mary Bennet. Marnie is the middle daughter: never considered as witty or as smart or as pretty as her sisters, she's the one who tries so hard and can't necessarily see when her efforts fall flat.

But Marnie is out to change that.

I particularly appreciate that this is a reinterpretation of Pride and Prejudice rather than a straight-up retelling—many recognisable characters, certainly, but clearly no need felt to stick to the original plot at all costs. This makes sense, because Mary Bennet didn't have all that much of a story in the original, but it's also helpful in that it gives Peterson a lot more room to make the story make sense for a different time and place.

Two things to note: first, this is teeeeeechnically a boarding-school book, but it might as well not be—Marnie spends more time with her family than with her classmates, and I don't think we ever see her in class. And second, the more I think about Marnie as Mary, the more I wonder about other Bennet stories untold: think about Lydia, who does not come off well in the original and is probably destined for quite an unhappy marriage. Or think about Jane, who never really goes beyond 'good and beautiful'. Or Kitty, who is mostly just...there. What might their stories look like if they were the protagonists in their own stories?

Review: "Northern Girls" by Michelle Willms

Northern Girls by Michelle Willms Published April 2026 via Baraka Books ★★★★ A brief memoir-in-essays about growing up in northern Ontario—w...