Doctor by Andrew Bomback
Published September 2018 via Bloomsbury Academic
★★★
Bomback's path to medicine was reasonably straightforward: with his own father a doctor, he had a clear sightline to what medicine could be. He went into nephrology, though, not pediatrics, and what he saw was a changing face of medicine—one that would eventually push his father, who was infinitely more comfortable with paper charts and quick, instinct- and experience-based diagnoses than he was with technology and insurance rules, out of practice.
I've read a lot of medical memoirs. I never had any interest in going into medicine myself, but I'll read about it until the cows come home. But...I think this book was a missed opportunity. It's part of Bloomsbury Academic's Object Lessons series—short books about common objects (or, in this case, I guess professions). The contents vary: sometimes the books are memoirs, but sometimes they're microhistories or cultural critiques. And there's a bit that is broader here (Bomback talks about where medicine is going—i.e., that everything now involves computers—relative to what it was in his father's heyday, although in 2025, now that the conversation is all about AI, Bomback's take already feels dated), but more than that it's personal story, which is to say memoir. Stories about Bomback's father; stories about Bomback's own patients; ventures into parenting (with a wife who is also a doctor and—Bomback mentions only in passing—both frustrated that she did not go into surgery and aware that balancing surgery and parenting would be difficult); and so on. And all of that's fine!*
But Object Lessons has the chance to do something so unique, and a medical memoir is not all that unique. I would have liked to see what this book was if it had taken the form of...the history of doctors, say. Or a cultural history of nephrology. (Is that a thing? Now we'll never know.) Or something specific to, oh, scalpels, or dialysis, or something like that. Maybe I just don't think that a doctor is a "thing"? Or perhaps I think it could be, but this book isn't exploring any of the questions I hoped it might. Fine if you're in it for anecdotal memoir, but with this series I always hope for something more.
* Well, most of it's fine. The chapter about callous doctor jokes felt unnecessary, and there's a moment when Bomback wonders who would love a blind and fat woman (a patient of his) and I wondered, not for the first time, just what they're teaching in medical school.
Monday, June 30, 2025
Sunday, June 29, 2025
Review: "Sonita" by Sonita Alizada
Sonita by Sonita Alizada
Published July 2025 via HarperOne
★★★
"Can you buy me?" I asked the Iranian filmmaker who had been documenting my life for three years. Now, it seemed her protagonist was about to be sold into marriage. What a terrible ending for a documentary.
"You have six months before your wedding," my mother said.
Enough time to plan my escape. (loc. 65*)
Growing up in Afghanistan, Alizada's path seemed clear: at some point her parents would find a husband for her, and then she'd be married and have children. The end. As a child, she didn't question this—a wedding would mean new clothing, a party, excitement. And with girls not allowed to go to school, she couldn't conceive of another possibility. But the older Alizada got, the more she saw how bleak her projected future looked.
Now that her veil was up, I recognized her. We had been at her wedding just a few months before. Why was she marrying again? I was too young to understand what scared her so much that the spoonful of cake in her hand trembled: after her husband died, she had to marry her brother-in-law. (loc. 589)
What follows is a harrowing story of a girl growing up and desperately trying to outsmart a system that didn't allow her any choice. It sounds like Alizada's family was constantly on the brink of poverty; money aside, not only could she as a girl not go to school, nobody in her family could read, and none of them had a real concept of the wider world:
"I am from Herat too," the man said. "The war has scattered all of us like seeds. My oldest sister is in Turkey, and my brothers are in America. Do you know where Turkey and America are?"
"So far we only only about Afghanistan, India, and Iran—are there more countries?" asked Razeq. The man looked at all of us and told us that there are many more countries that we haven't even seen pictures of. (loc. 1351)
As refugees in Iran, their lives were safer—no threat of being snatched off the street by the Taliban—but not less fraught. As undocumented immigrants, they still had no rights; they still could not go to school. Besides, Alizada's parents didn't see the point: Nana and Baba reminded me that there was no need for me to know how to write names. Soon I would be married, and learning to write my husband's name was no accomplishment if I couldn't make him food. (loc. 1786) And they did not see a future in Iran, either; their homeland was Afghanistan, Taliban or no Taliban.
It's a difficult read. Alizada is so blunt about the things she saw and experienced, and it makes for the kind of painful and raw read that required, especially early on, reading in short bursts rather than plunging on through. The writing is a bit hit or miss, but it's a really valuable story. I read Khalida Popal's My Beautiful Sisters recently, and the similarities and differences are so striking—Popal's family had more financial advantages and was much more supportive of her going to school, using her voice, etc., but both women were trapped under the same regime and determined that there must be something better. They both got out (not a spoiler), but the details differ...except that for both women it required incredible amounts of determination and bravery. And it feels especially important to read women's stories from Afghanistan now, when so few women there can safely share those stories.
I won't get into the rap music part of things here, but it's an important part of the story—worth looking up Alizada's song "Daughters for Sale".
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
*Quotes are from an ARC and may not be final.
Published July 2025 via HarperOne
★★★
"Can you buy me?" I asked the Iranian filmmaker who had been documenting my life for three years. Now, it seemed her protagonist was about to be sold into marriage. What a terrible ending for a documentary.
"You have six months before your wedding," my mother said.
Enough time to plan my escape. (loc. 65*)
Growing up in Afghanistan, Alizada's path seemed clear: at some point her parents would find a husband for her, and then she'd be married and have children. The end. As a child, she didn't question this—a wedding would mean new clothing, a party, excitement. And with girls not allowed to go to school, she couldn't conceive of another possibility. But the older Alizada got, the more she saw how bleak her projected future looked.
Now that her veil was up, I recognized her. We had been at her wedding just a few months before. Why was she marrying again? I was too young to understand what scared her so much that the spoonful of cake in her hand trembled: after her husband died, she had to marry her brother-in-law. (loc. 589)
What follows is a harrowing story of a girl growing up and desperately trying to outsmart a system that didn't allow her any choice. It sounds like Alizada's family was constantly on the brink of poverty; money aside, not only could she as a girl not go to school, nobody in her family could read, and none of them had a real concept of the wider world:
"I am from Herat too," the man said. "The war has scattered all of us like seeds. My oldest sister is in Turkey, and my brothers are in America. Do you know where Turkey and America are?"
"So far we only only about Afghanistan, India, and Iran—are there more countries?" asked Razeq. The man looked at all of us and told us that there are many more countries that we haven't even seen pictures of. (loc. 1351)
As refugees in Iran, their lives were safer—no threat of being snatched off the street by the Taliban—but not less fraught. As undocumented immigrants, they still had no rights; they still could not go to school. Besides, Alizada's parents didn't see the point: Nana and Baba reminded me that there was no need for me to know how to write names. Soon I would be married, and learning to write my husband's name was no accomplishment if I couldn't make him food. (loc. 1786) And they did not see a future in Iran, either; their homeland was Afghanistan, Taliban or no Taliban.
It's a difficult read. Alizada is so blunt about the things she saw and experienced, and it makes for the kind of painful and raw read that required, especially early on, reading in short bursts rather than plunging on through. The writing is a bit hit or miss, but it's a really valuable story. I read Khalida Popal's My Beautiful Sisters recently, and the similarities and differences are so striking—Popal's family had more financial advantages and was much more supportive of her going to school, using her voice, etc., but both women were trapped under the same regime and determined that there must be something better. They both got out (not a spoiler), but the details differ...except that for both women it required incredible amounts of determination and bravery. And it feels especially important to read women's stories from Afghanistan now, when so few women there can safely share those stories.
I won't get into the rap music part of things here, but it's an important part of the story—worth looking up Alizada's song "Daughters for Sale".
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
*Quotes are from an ARC and may not be final.
Saturday, June 28, 2025
Review: "Still Falling" by S.E. Bevin
Still Falling by S.E. Bevin
Published April 2025
★★★
Year twelve is approaching, and Tessa has it together—good grades, increasing gymnastics skills, a loving family. But her friend and teammate Jade is convinced that being lighter is the key to success at the gym, and Tessa can't help but think that Jade is right—that her shrinking figure indicates a level of control and achievement that Tessa too should strive for.
The writing is nice here and the story clear. The book is quite short (under 150 pages, according to Kindle), which I think is to its detriment; although it's nicely paced, there's no room in the story for anything but Tessa's eating disorder. I'd have loved to see more of Tessa and Jade's friendship before their eating disorders, as at the moment Jade is really nothing but a voice in Tessa's ear shaming her for eating. Would also have liked to see more of Tessa's family life; her family seems lovely, but their role is mostly limited to being worried over how little Tessa is eating.
So a little simple, but all in all a nice debut, especially from a self-published (and I think quite young?) author.
Published April 2025
★★★
Year twelve is approaching, and Tessa has it together—good grades, increasing gymnastics skills, a loving family. But her friend and teammate Jade is convinced that being lighter is the key to success at the gym, and Tessa can't help but think that Jade is right—that her shrinking figure indicates a level of control and achievement that Tessa too should strive for.
The writing is nice here and the story clear. The book is quite short (under 150 pages, according to Kindle), which I think is to its detriment; although it's nicely paced, there's no room in the story for anything but Tessa's eating disorder. I'd have loved to see more of Tessa and Jade's friendship before their eating disorders, as at the moment Jade is really nothing but a voice in Tessa's ear shaming her for eating. Would also have liked to see more of Tessa's family life; her family seems lovely, but their role is mostly limited to being worried over how little Tessa is eating.
So a little simple, but all in all a nice debut, especially from a self-published (and I think quite young?) author.
Thursday, June 26, 2025
Review: "The Real Jaws" by Rachel Lee Perez
The Real Jaws by Rachel Lee Perez
Published June 2025 via White Owl
★★★
Did you know that the first known representation of a shark attack is from 725 BCE...? I did not! And did you know that the movie Jaws has some basis in fact—a series of 1916 shark attacks on the New Jersey coast? I did not know that either.
In The Real Jaws, Perez dives into the history of those shark attacks and, critically, how they impacted the way people viewed sharks. I'm not entirely new to shark research (I once upon a time wrote an essay that was partly about sharks and that referenced some of the same sources she uses, which amuses me), but I wasn't familiar with the 1916 attacks or the other seasons of increased shark activity in various places. I did read the Wikipedia article on the 1916 attacks before I read the book—which I then regretted, because there would have been a bit more suspense for that part of the book if I hadn't known what to expect.
So it's fascinating material. Perez takes to the subject with plenty of enthusiasm (if a few too many exclamation marks) and a lot of research—anyone who likes leaping from a book into the reference section will be satisfied here. The beginning of the book has a timeline, which is full of events (e.g., polio outbreaks, war activities) that I initially thought were just for context but Perez tied neatly into the context of sharks and shark-human encounters. I don't take every conclusion at face value (e.g., Perez says that even the ISAF [International Shark Attack File] suggests on their website that people actively menstruating should avoid swimming in open water to reduce one's odds of being attacked by a shark (loc. 1562*), but what the ISAF actually says is much softer: If someone is attempting to maximize reduction of risks, staying out of the water during menstruation is one step that can be taken. However, many people safely dive while menstruating, and we have continued to see no obvious pattern of increased shark encounters.), but that's probably smart for most nonfiction; treat one source as one source but not as a definitive source without, erm, consulting other sources.
Writing-wise, this could have used another extensive round of line-level edits. I liked the overall structure (starting with the 1916 attacks and then moving on to theories about what caused so much shark activity, more recent shark-heavy seasons, and of course Jaws), but I spent far too long on lines like this one: This [multiple bites] is outside the standard behavior when a shark mistakenly bites a human. Why did the shark repeatedly bite Bruder when surely it must have known that its victim was indeed a human being? (loc. 625)
Perez later gets into what science now thinks about sharks—among other things, that they use biting to examine unknown things (they don't exactly have fingers to do the same job!)—but I was stuck on the fact that even if a shark bit somebody once and realized in doing so that it wasn't a seal, it wouldn't know the thing was specifically human; most likely it would just know that the thing it had bitten was living but not a seal or fish or whatever. Given that Perez also notes that violent language (attack, bite, deadly, etc.; e.g., loc. 2168) has widely been used to describe sharks and their interactions with humans, and that such language contributes to a public view of sharks as monsters, I also would have liked to see her use quite a bit less of the same language (my Kindle counts some 718 uses of the word "attack", though I should note that this includes the references, the table of contents, etc.).
All of this said: I learned a lot, and I came home from work with my nose buried in my Kindle and said absentmindedly to my partner, "Can we watch Jaws?" (and then went back to my book). An engaging read if you want to learn a bit about a forgotten (and gory) part of history, or if you need a shark week read.
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
*Quotes are from an ARC and may not be final.
Published June 2025 via White Owl
★★★
Did you know that the first known representation of a shark attack is from 725 BCE...? I did not! And did you know that the movie Jaws has some basis in fact—a series of 1916 shark attacks on the New Jersey coast? I did not know that either.
In The Real Jaws, Perez dives into the history of those shark attacks and, critically, how they impacted the way people viewed sharks. I'm not entirely new to shark research (I once upon a time wrote an essay that was partly about sharks and that referenced some of the same sources she uses, which amuses me), but I wasn't familiar with the 1916 attacks or the other seasons of increased shark activity in various places. I did read the Wikipedia article on the 1916 attacks before I read the book—which I then regretted, because there would have been a bit more suspense for that part of the book if I hadn't known what to expect.
So it's fascinating material. Perez takes to the subject with plenty of enthusiasm (if a few too many exclamation marks) and a lot of research—anyone who likes leaping from a book into the reference section will be satisfied here. The beginning of the book has a timeline, which is full of events (e.g., polio outbreaks, war activities) that I initially thought were just for context but Perez tied neatly into the context of sharks and shark-human encounters. I don't take every conclusion at face value (e.g., Perez says that even the ISAF [International Shark Attack File] suggests on their website that people actively menstruating should avoid swimming in open water to reduce one's odds of being attacked by a shark (loc. 1562*), but what the ISAF actually says is much softer: If someone is attempting to maximize reduction of risks, staying out of the water during menstruation is one step that can be taken. However, many people safely dive while menstruating, and we have continued to see no obvious pattern of increased shark encounters.), but that's probably smart for most nonfiction; treat one source as one source but not as a definitive source without, erm, consulting other sources.
Writing-wise, this could have used another extensive round of line-level edits. I liked the overall structure (starting with the 1916 attacks and then moving on to theories about what caused so much shark activity, more recent shark-heavy seasons, and of course Jaws), but I spent far too long on lines like this one: This [multiple bites] is outside the standard behavior when a shark mistakenly bites a human. Why did the shark repeatedly bite Bruder when surely it must have known that its victim was indeed a human being? (loc. 625)
Perez later gets into what science now thinks about sharks—among other things, that they use biting to examine unknown things (they don't exactly have fingers to do the same job!)—but I was stuck on the fact that even if a shark bit somebody once and realized in doing so that it wasn't a seal, it wouldn't know the thing was specifically human; most likely it would just know that the thing it had bitten was living but not a seal or fish or whatever. Given that Perez also notes that violent language (attack, bite, deadly, etc.; e.g., loc. 2168) has widely been used to describe sharks and their interactions with humans, and that such language contributes to a public view of sharks as monsters, I also would have liked to see her use quite a bit less of the same language (my Kindle counts some 718 uses of the word "attack", though I should note that this includes the references, the table of contents, etc.).
All of this said: I learned a lot, and I came home from work with my nose buried in my Kindle and said absentmindedly to my partner, "Can we watch Jaws?" (and then went back to my book). An engaging read if you want to learn a bit about a forgotten (and gory) part of history, or if you need a shark week read.
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
*Quotes are from an ARC and may not be final.
Wednesday, June 25, 2025
Review: "Danger on Midnight River" by Gary Paulsen
Danger on Midnight River by Gary Paulsen
Published 1995
★★★
Oh gosh, okay. I've been going through a...not really a Gary Paulsen phase, but a childhood-rereads phase, and I'm in the Gary Paulsen phase of my childhood-rereads phase. I think we must have owned a copy of this book—I know I read it multiple times, and some parts (eating pine cones warmed by a fire) I remembered pretty clearly.
Spoilers ahead. But also, the book is 30 years old, so chances are good that if you're on this page you too have read the book before.
As a kids' book I still think this is pretty great. It's lively, and it's a story where not only does the underdog prove his worth, but the bullies voluntarily (eventually) come to their senses. Plus, you never know; maybe one of these days I'll get lost on a mountain and survive by eating pine cones, and I'll have this book to thank for it.
But I reread it as an adult. And with an adult's eyes, I have some questions. Like: When Daniel crawls out of the van, he doesn't think for a second about the other boys? He gets to the bank and starts a fire and starts to dry out his clothes...and only gives the others (dead or alive) a second thought when he hears voices. (And even then he takes the time to build up his fire before going to check it out.) Granted, Daniel owes the other boys nothing (they've been consistently terrible to him), but my gosh.
The number of perils these kids face is wild. In addition to their van crashing and the driver dying (Paulsen really liked to kill off the adults, didn't he?), one of the boys is trapped and almost drowns. The boys split up (TERRIBLE DECISION, CHILDREN; LEARN FROM THIS), and the three of them who are not Daniel immediately get lost, get sprayed by a skunk, and spend a miserable night in the rain...and then one of them falls off a cliff and breaks his leg. Daniel shows up just in time to save the day, of course, and performs a heroic and improbable rescue with some belts. (I've read my fair share of wilderness rescue memoir, and I rather suspect that a real-life version of this would have the injured kid screaming quite a bit more rather than just the occasional wince.) And if that's not enough, there's still a rabid dog and another near-drowning to keep the boys on their toes.
Again, this is a kids' book. The fact pace makes a certain amount of sense, and you can do away with occasional logic. But as an adult I'm bad at doing away with logic (well, except when I'm very good at doing away with logic, but this is not one of those times), so here we are. When Daniel insists that they boil their water before drinking it, how? Like, sensible, I'm not complaining, but... Earlier in the book we see that he's found "a large rock with a hollowed-out center", and somehow if there's a small fire nearby this will boil (would love to test this in real life—can you boil water by just putting it next to a fire, not above one? How big a fire is required to boil how much water?). But that was ages ago in the book, and even if they found that rock again (he hasn't been lugging it around), how did they move enough water from the river to the rock that they could drink boiled water "until they thought they would burst"?
I miss being a kid and not questioning these things.
I will note that earlier in the book Daniel suggests that they have three options—stay put and light a signal fire, try to continue on the road they were going on, or try to cross the river again and go back the way they came. The other three boys want to continue on the unknown road, and Daniel wants to go back the way they came. And I just don't know what to make of this. Daniel estimates that they went maybe a hundred miles in the wrong direction and took random turns along the way, so I can't possibly imagine that he thinks they'll happen upon the right turns and so on. I suppose he's hoping they'll get onto a bigger road and run into someone. But I can't help but think that the smarter thing to do would be to start with a signal fire—Daniel's proven himself perfectly capable of starting that fire and keeping all four boys fed and watered, and they'd have a lot fewer chances to fall off cliffs and almost drown if they just stayed put and built a smoky fire.
Oh well. It was fun, anyway. Ooh, one of these days I'll have to find that Sweet Valley High book where there's an earthquake and Jessica tries (and fails) to use her belt to rescue someone who's fallen down a chasm in the earth...
Published 1995
★★★
Oh gosh, okay. I've been going through a...not really a Gary Paulsen phase, but a childhood-rereads phase, and I'm in the Gary Paulsen phase of my childhood-rereads phase. I think we must have owned a copy of this book—I know I read it multiple times, and some parts (eating pine cones warmed by a fire) I remembered pretty clearly.
Spoilers ahead. But also, the book is 30 years old, so chances are good that if you're on this page you too have read the book before.
As a kids' book I still think this is pretty great. It's lively, and it's a story where not only does the underdog prove his worth, but the bullies voluntarily (eventually) come to their senses. Plus, you never know; maybe one of these days I'll get lost on a mountain and survive by eating pine cones, and I'll have this book to thank for it.
But I reread it as an adult. And with an adult's eyes, I have some questions. Like: When Daniel crawls out of the van, he doesn't think for a second about the other boys? He gets to the bank and starts a fire and starts to dry out his clothes...and only gives the others (dead or alive) a second thought when he hears voices. (And even then he takes the time to build up his fire before going to check it out.) Granted, Daniel owes the other boys nothing (they've been consistently terrible to him), but my gosh.
The number of perils these kids face is wild. In addition to their van crashing and the driver dying (Paulsen really liked to kill off the adults, didn't he?), one of the boys is trapped and almost drowns. The boys split up (TERRIBLE DECISION, CHILDREN; LEARN FROM THIS), and the three of them who are not Daniel immediately get lost, get sprayed by a skunk, and spend a miserable night in the rain...and then one of them falls off a cliff and breaks his leg. Daniel shows up just in time to save the day, of course, and performs a heroic and improbable rescue with some belts. (I've read my fair share of wilderness rescue memoir, and I rather suspect that a real-life version of this would have the injured kid screaming quite a bit more rather than just the occasional wince.) And if that's not enough, there's still a rabid dog and another near-drowning to keep the boys on their toes.
Again, this is a kids' book. The fact pace makes a certain amount of sense, and you can do away with occasional logic. But as an adult I'm bad at doing away with logic (well, except when I'm very good at doing away with logic, but this is not one of those times), so here we are. When Daniel insists that they boil their water before drinking it, how? Like, sensible, I'm not complaining, but... Earlier in the book we see that he's found "a large rock with a hollowed-out center", and somehow if there's a small fire nearby this will boil (would love to test this in real life—can you boil water by just putting it next to a fire, not above one? How big a fire is required to boil how much water?). But that was ages ago in the book, and even if they found that rock again (he hasn't been lugging it around), how did they move enough water from the river to the rock that they could drink boiled water "until they thought they would burst"?
I miss being a kid and not questioning these things.
I will note that earlier in the book Daniel suggests that they have three options—stay put and light a signal fire, try to continue on the road they were going on, or try to cross the river again and go back the way they came. The other three boys want to continue on the unknown road, and Daniel wants to go back the way they came. And I just don't know what to make of this. Daniel estimates that they went maybe a hundred miles in the wrong direction and took random turns along the way, so I can't possibly imagine that he thinks they'll happen upon the right turns and so on. I suppose he's hoping they'll get onto a bigger road and run into someone. But I can't help but think that the smarter thing to do would be to start with a signal fire—Daniel's proven himself perfectly capable of starting that fire and keeping all four boys fed and watered, and they'd have a lot fewer chances to fall off cliffs and almost drown if they just stayed put and built a smoky fire.
Oh well. It was fun, anyway. Ooh, one of these days I'll have to find that Sweet Valley High book where there's an earthquake and Jessica tries (and fails) to use her belt to rescue someone who's fallen down a chasm in the earth...
Tuesday, June 24, 2025
Review: Essay: "The Shelter Within" by Stephanie Land
The Shelter Within by Stephanie Land
Published June 2024 via Amazon Original Stories
You may remember Land's first book, Maid, about poverty and single-parenting and, yes, cleaning houses. I read it long enough ago that I don't remember it terribly well, but in "The Shelter Within" she returns, briefly, to what that poverty looked like: mildew in the apartment, not enough money to put down a deposit on a new one, not enough money to feed both herself and her seven-year-old daughter, no chance of paid parental leave following the birth of her infant daughter, not enough money to do anything but scrape by.
This is a reminder that poverty can be white-collar too—in theory Land had now "made it", because she was living somewhere she wanted to be and had completed college, but she was working two part-time writing jobs, neither of which paid anything close to covering the costs of basic necessities. But more than that, it's a timely reminder that the US has not historically given much help to those who are financially floundering, and with the current administration that will only get worse. Land may not have been thinking about politics while writing this essay, but it's inescapable: she was already stretched to the bone in the period she describes here and could not have worked more hours, earned more money, especially without childcare—which would have been a whole 'nother expense. Maybe it's not the point, but it's hard not to see it in the current economic and political climate.
Ultimately this is a story of hope. That hope was eventually born out—Land wrote Maid, which changed the trajectory of her career and hopefully put her on permanently stable financial footing—but even before that she describes the small and not so small moments that gave her hope that things would work out. Most people won't write an instant bestseller, but most people will find those small and not so small moments.
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
Published June 2024 via Amazon Original Stories
You may remember Land's first book, Maid, about poverty and single-parenting and, yes, cleaning houses. I read it long enough ago that I don't remember it terribly well, but in "The Shelter Within" she returns, briefly, to what that poverty looked like: mildew in the apartment, not enough money to put down a deposit on a new one, not enough money to feed both herself and her seven-year-old daughter, no chance of paid parental leave following the birth of her infant daughter, not enough money to do anything but scrape by.
This is a reminder that poverty can be white-collar too—in theory Land had now "made it", because she was living somewhere she wanted to be and had completed college, but she was working two part-time writing jobs, neither of which paid anything close to covering the costs of basic necessities. But more than that, it's a timely reminder that the US has not historically given much help to those who are financially floundering, and with the current administration that will only get worse. Land may not have been thinking about politics while writing this essay, but it's inescapable: she was already stretched to the bone in the period she describes here and could not have worked more hours, earned more money, especially without childcare—which would have been a whole 'nother expense. Maybe it's not the point, but it's hard not to see it in the current economic and political climate.
Ultimately this is a story of hope. That hope was eventually born out—Land wrote Maid, which changed the trajectory of her career and hopefully put her on permanently stable financial footing—but even before that she describes the small and not so small moments that gave her hope that things would work out. Most people won't write an instant bestseller, but most people will find those small and not so small moments.
Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.
Monday, June 23, 2025
Review: "The River" by Gary Paulsen
The River by Gary Paulsen
Published 1991
★★★
Book 2 in the Hatchet books, which I read as book 3 because that was the order that makes sense to me. Here, Brian is asked to take on a government project—to return to the wild and show a psychologist, in real time, how he did what he did. Things go well, maybe even too well...until they don't. And then Brian has to take on a new task: get the psychologist, who is unconscious after a lightning strike, some 100 miles downriver.
As with Brian's Winter, this is an interesting addition to the series but doesn't have quite the same power as Hatchet. By this point in the series (again, book 2), Brian is an old hand at it all—anything outdoors that he sets his mind to he more or less immediately achieves. Not that I want a perfectly inoffensive character to struggle unduly, but Brian very much goes into this challenge thinking (and then executing), "okay, we need X, then Y, then Z". Might have been more realistic to put Brian in an environment he wasn't quite so familiar with and have him need to look for different kinds of berries, nuts, etc.? I'm not sure. Then again, even when Brian has to make a raft that will safely navigate two adults, one unconscious, down a river, it's nothing more than a half-day's work to him even when this is well outside his normal skill set. Maybe it would just be more realistic for a couple of months of ad-hoc survival to not turn him into an expert at all things outdoors.
Still glad to have given this series a reread, but next time I think I'd probably be okay with sticking with book 1 and then moving on to other things.
Published 1991
★★★
Book 2 in the Hatchet books, which I read as book 3 because that was the order that makes sense to me. Here, Brian is asked to take on a government project—to return to the wild and show a psychologist, in real time, how he did what he did. Things go well, maybe even too well...until they don't. And then Brian has to take on a new task: get the psychologist, who is unconscious after a lightning strike, some 100 miles downriver.
As with Brian's Winter, this is an interesting addition to the series but doesn't have quite the same power as Hatchet. By this point in the series (again, book 2), Brian is an old hand at it all—anything outdoors that he sets his mind to he more or less immediately achieves. Not that I want a perfectly inoffensive character to struggle unduly, but Brian very much goes into this challenge thinking (and then executing), "okay, we need X, then Y, then Z". Might have been more realistic to put Brian in an environment he wasn't quite so familiar with and have him need to look for different kinds of berries, nuts, etc.? I'm not sure. Then again, even when Brian has to make a raft that will safely navigate two adults, one unconscious, down a river, it's nothing more than a half-day's work to him even when this is well outside his normal skill set. Maybe it would just be more realistic for a couple of months of ad-hoc survival to not turn him into an expert at all things outdoors.
Still glad to have given this series a reread, but next time I think I'd probably be okay with sticking with book 1 and then moving on to other things.
Saturday, June 21, 2025
Review: "Brian's Winter" by Gary Paulsen
Brian's Winter by Gary Paulsen
Published 1996
★★★
This is book 3 in the Hatchet books, but I skipped ahead because in my fuzzy memories of childhood, this was the second of the books that I read, and it's a more direct follow-up to Hatchet.
Brian's Winter reimagines the end of Hatchet: instead of the survival supplies Brian pulls out of the submerged plane leading to his rescue at the end of summer, they improve his odds—but he's still lost in the wild when summer rolls into autumn and then into winter.
While still a reasonably gripping read, this one felt a bit more "checklist" to me than Hatchet. By the time winter rolls around, Brian is confident in his abilities; he's justifiably worried about winter, but pretty much every time a concern comes up he thinks about it and finds a way to solve it. Perhaps that's partly because this is so short a book, with less character development and so on than the first one; it's also not one that I'd want to read without the context of the first book. But as a nostalgia read, I'm on board.
Published 1996
★★★
This is book 3 in the Hatchet books, but I skipped ahead because in my fuzzy memories of childhood, this was the second of the books that I read, and it's a more direct follow-up to Hatchet.
Brian's Winter reimagines the end of Hatchet: instead of the survival supplies Brian pulls out of the submerged plane leading to his rescue at the end of summer, they improve his odds—but he's still lost in the wild when summer rolls into autumn and then into winter.
While still a reasonably gripping read, this one felt a bit more "checklist" to me than Hatchet. By the time winter rolls around, Brian is confident in his abilities; he's justifiably worried about winter, but pretty much every time a concern comes up he thinks about it and finds a way to solve it. Perhaps that's partly because this is so short a book, with less character development and so on than the first one; it's also not one that I'd want to read without the context of the first book. But as a nostalgia read, I'm on board.
Thursday, June 19, 2025
Review: "Hatchet" by Gary Paulsen
Hatchet by Gary Paulsen
Published 1987
★★★★
I read Running Wild and got a yen to reread this. They're very different books, of course, and Hatchet is ultimately a nostalgia read for me. (How many kids of my generation read this in middle school?) It's the ultimate survival story: a boy unprepared for the wild crash-lands alone in remote Canada after the pilot flying their small plane has a heart attack. At first he thinks he'll just have to survive a few days, and then it becomes clear that he'll have to learn to be sufficient for rather longer.
I'm thinking now that Hatchet played at least a supporting role in my love of wilderness and survival stories. This is so unlike a contemporary survival story, even one written for the same age group (YA and MG lit were not the same established categories in 1987, when this was written, that they are now). I mean, just the fact that Brian has a hatchet on his trip to visit his father! He's not terribly resourceful to begin with, but he gets there—he has to grow up so quickly, because it's immediately obvious that just about anything in the wild can kill him.
Curious now about what the contemporary equivalent of this is; Running Wild is grand but also spans only a few days, and with kids who are better prepared to face the wild. And now I have a yen to reread Island of the Blue Dolphins as well...and maybe some more Gary Paulsen...
Published 1987
★★★★
I read Running Wild and got a yen to reread this. They're very different books, of course, and Hatchet is ultimately a nostalgia read for me. (How many kids of my generation read this in middle school?) It's the ultimate survival story: a boy unprepared for the wild crash-lands alone in remote Canada after the pilot flying their small plane has a heart attack. At first he thinks he'll just have to survive a few days, and then it becomes clear that he'll have to learn to be sufficient for rather longer.
I'm thinking now that Hatchet played at least a supporting role in my love of wilderness and survival stories. This is so unlike a contemporary survival story, even one written for the same age group (YA and MG lit were not the same established categories in 1987, when this was written, that they are now). I mean, just the fact that Brian has a hatchet on his trip to visit his father! He's not terribly resourceful to begin with, but he gets there—he has to grow up so quickly, because it's immediately obvious that just about anything in the wild can kill him.
Curious now about what the contemporary equivalent of this is; Running Wild is grand but also spans only a few days, and with kids who are better prepared to face the wild. And now I have a yen to reread Island of the Blue Dolphins as well...and maybe some more Gary Paulsen...
Wednesday, June 18, 2025
Review: "The School at the Chalet" by Elinor M. Brent-Dyer
The School at the Chalet by Elinor M. Brent-Dyer
Published 1925
★★★
Nostalgia reading at its finest. My mother grew up reading these, so my siblings and I grew up reading them too—we had piles of them. They were a huge part of my desire to go to boarding school (and a huge part of the reason boarding school—not in an idealized version of the Austrian Alps, and not in an idealized version of the 1920s/30s/40s—was so disorienting when I did eventually go).
Anyway, curiosity (and nostalgia) called, so here I am. And rereading this was...something. It's so much a product of its time and place that I'm not entirely sure what to do with it anymore: The girls are all basically (with a few exceptions) simple and sweet and good; the adults are all basically smart and sweet and good; the England Be Glad sense is real. Madge sets up shop in the Alps and immediately has people pounding on her door to enroll their daughters, because thank goodness there's now an English school in the Tyrol, how did we possibly educate our children without a good proper English school. She's making it all up as she goes—school fees are decided not by any calculation of costs but by Madge asking her brother if he thinks £120/year sounds reasonable. The local girls are considered the foreigners; the local adults inexplicably say "thee" and "thou" a lot; Madge begrudgingly appoints a "foreigner" as head girl because the English girls are too young.
Brent-Dyer doesn't seem to have been fond of Germans (she remarks that There is much more camaraderie between Austrians and their children than between Germans and theirs, and the Tyrolese middle class and upper middle class treat their boys and girls nearly conforming to English ideals), and there is an epic—not in a good way—running "joke" throughout the book about a fat German woman some of the girls meet. Everyone is appallingly rude—the kids, the German woman—but the adults who should be teaching the kids to do better seem to think that the German woman is automatically in the wrong because she's fat. It's one part of the book that has aged very badly (and it wasn't a good part of the book to begin with).
I'll read a bit farther into the series and see where it gets me. The lustre has come off a bit, though I expect I'll manage to forget some of my disappointment within a few years and do another read...
Counts:
Dainty: 10 (dainty uniform, dainty meal...)
Jolly: 38 (jolly clever, jolly man...)
Pretty: 28+ (her pretty head, her pretty little watch, her pretty broken German...)
Honest injun: 5. Joey is the culprit here, but everyone seems to think it's fine.
Published 1925
★★★
Nostalgia reading at its finest. My mother grew up reading these, so my siblings and I grew up reading them too—we had piles of them. They were a huge part of my desire to go to boarding school (and a huge part of the reason boarding school—not in an idealized version of the Austrian Alps, and not in an idealized version of the 1920s/30s/40s—was so disorienting when I did eventually go).
Anyway, curiosity (and nostalgia) called, so here I am. And rereading this was...something. It's so much a product of its time and place that I'm not entirely sure what to do with it anymore: The girls are all basically (with a few exceptions) simple and sweet and good; the adults are all basically smart and sweet and good; the England Be Glad sense is real. Madge sets up shop in the Alps and immediately has people pounding on her door to enroll their daughters, because thank goodness there's now an English school in the Tyrol, how did we possibly educate our children without a good proper English school. She's making it all up as she goes—school fees are decided not by any calculation of costs but by Madge asking her brother if he thinks £120/year sounds reasonable. The local girls are considered the foreigners; the local adults inexplicably say "thee" and "thou" a lot; Madge begrudgingly appoints a "foreigner" as head girl because the English girls are too young.
Brent-Dyer doesn't seem to have been fond of Germans (she remarks that There is much more camaraderie between Austrians and their children than between Germans and theirs, and the Tyrolese middle class and upper middle class treat their boys and girls nearly conforming to English ideals), and there is an epic—not in a good way—running "joke" throughout the book about a fat German woman some of the girls meet. Everyone is appallingly rude—the kids, the German woman—but the adults who should be teaching the kids to do better seem to think that the German woman is automatically in the wrong because she's fat. It's one part of the book that has aged very badly (and it wasn't a good part of the book to begin with).
I'll read a bit farther into the series and see where it gets me. The lustre has come off a bit, though I expect I'll manage to forget some of my disappointment within a few years and do another read...
Counts:
Dainty: 10 (dainty uniform, dainty meal...)
Jolly: 38 (jolly clever, jolly man...)
Pretty: 28+ (her pretty head, her pretty little watch, her pretty broken German...)
Honest injun: 5. Joey is the culprit here, but everyone seems to think it's fine.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Review: "Northern Girls" by Michelle Willms
Northern Girls by Michelle Willms Published April 2026 via Baraka Books ★★★★ A brief memoir-in-essays about growing up in northern Ontario—w...
-
The Ferryman and His Wife by Frode Grytten, translated from the Norwegian by Alison McCullough Published November 2025 via Algonquin Books ★...
-
The Keeper by Tana French Published March 2026 via Viking ★★★★ Book three—of three—in the Cal Hooper series. Time has passed: Trey is growin...
-
The Trad Wife by Carrie Hughes Published May 2026 via Hera ★★★ Melissa's not living the trad wife life, not by a long shot—she's a s...









