Review: "Say a Little Prayer" by Jenna Voris

Say a Little Prayer by Jenna Voris
Published March 2025 via Viking Books for Young Readers
★★★★

Church used to be a comfortable place for Riley—until she realized that her queerness would never be accepted, and until the pastor threw her sister Hannah out for getting an abortion. She doesn't regret leaving and not going back...except that she's been quietly in love with the pastor's daughter for years. And except that the pastor isn't happy that she left without his say-so. And except that after an altercation at school, she's been banished to church camp in Kentucky for a week...and now things are just a little bit awkward.

This is so far up my alley it's basically in my backyard. I love that although Riley feels rejected by the church, she isn't rejected by the people she loves most; her family has zero problem with sexuality, and neither does Julia, her best-friend-slash-crush. Better, the deeper into the book we get, the more complicated she finds her relationship with the teenagers who have been making her life, and her sister's life, difficult since they found out about Hannah's abortion. Riley is very much a teenager (her rantings in her notebook are ever so slightly cringe, which fortunately I think is the point), but on the whole things feel balanced.

Readers who have read Voris's Every Time You Hear That Song will be pleased to find a few easter eggs (though this is not a sequel and can be read 100% independently of Every Time). I read Say a Little Prayer partly on the strength of Every Time, and I'm pleased to report that Prayer lives up to the standard set by its predecessor.

Thanks to the author and publisher for providing a review copy through NetGalley.